1. Introduction
Metric spaces serve as one of the cornerstone of topology and analysis, providing a framework for measuring distances between elements in a set. Extensions of this concept have been developed to address more general situations, such as quasi-metrics [
8], partial metrics [
17] and probabilistic metric spaces (PMSs) [
20]. Quantale-valued generalized metric spaces introduced by Flagg [
6], also known as continuity spaces, is a significant generalization of metric spaces. This generalized metric space notion provides a unified setting that combines order theoretic and metric notions. Quantale-valued metric space is obtained by changing the value set
of a classical metric space with a quantale. Within the framework of quantale-valued generalized metric spaces, one can recover metric spaces and probabilistic metric spaces as special examples. Moreover, these structures play a significant role in quantitative domain theory and denotational semantics, see [
9]. For more detailed work on these spaces, see [
11,
12,
13,
14,
15,
21,
22].
The Banach Contraction Principle [
2] led to significant attention for fixed point theory (FPT) which is regarded as a powerful instrument in various diciplines. A variety of extensions of the Banach Fixed Point Theorem have been developed, with the coupled fixed point theorem being a prominent example. This notion was initially presented by Bhaskar and Lakshmikantham [
3] and was later expanded by Sabetghadam et al. [
19] into the structure of complete cone metric spaces. While FPT has seen substantial progress across numerous generalized metric frameworks, research focusing on fixed point theorems within quantale-valued generalized metric spaces remains rather limited. In this paper, the term quantale-valued quasi-metric space (QVQMS) will be used to denote a separated quantale-valued generalized metric space.
We arrange the paper in the following mannner: In the second section, we present some preliminary definitions and properties that will be frequently used throughout the paper. In the third section, inspired by the works of [
5] and [
19], we establish coupled fixed point results in quantale-valued quasi-metric spaces. Some of results obtained [
19] will be extended to this broader setting. In the final section, we extend the notion of 0-completeness introduced in [
18] for quantale-valued partial metric spaces [
16] and introduce the concept of
-completeness. Motivated by the study of [
10], which reveals that fixed point results established in partial metric spaces can be obtained as consequences of those in metric spaces, we apply our main theorem from section 2 to the quantale-valued partial metric space context. Moreover, since probabilistic metric spaces can be regarded as quantale-valued quasi-metric spaces, we end the paper by deriving a coupled fixed point results for probabilistic metric spaces. The newly obtained fixed point theorems are expected to fill a gap in the literature and open perspectives for applications denotational semantics and theoretical computer science.
2. Preliminaries
Let
be a complete lattice, where every subset has a supremum and infimum. We will denote the bottom and top elements of the complete latice
Q by
and
e, respectively. The well above relation defined below is an extension of the strict inequality relation in [
6], formulated in the context of complete lattices.
Definition 1 (Well above relation, [
6]).
Let be a complete lattice. Let . Then, p is said to be well above q, symbolized as , if the following holds:
Moreover, if the following condition holds for all , then Q is called completely distributive lattice:
Definition 2 (Value quantale, [
6]).
A value quantale is defined as a triple satisfying the following requirements for all and :
is a completely distributive lattice;
On Q, ⊕ serves as a binary operation satisfying associativity and commutativity;
;
;
and if and , then .
Let . The mapping is given by:
for further details on its properties, see [6].
Definition 3 (Quantale-Valued Quasi Metric, see [
6]).
Consider a nonempty set S and value quantale . A mapping is referred as a quantale-valued quasi-metric whenever for all , the conditions below are satisfied:
The pair is referred as quantale-valued quasi-metric space (also called a separated continuity space in [6]).
Consider a quantale-valued quasi-metric space
. Let
. Then the mappings
(dual of
) and
(symmetrization of
) are specified respectively by
see [
5]. For the topological properties of this space, the reader may consult [
4,
5,
6,
7] for further details. Consider a net
in
S.
is symmetrically convergent to
whenever for any
, there exists
such that for all
,
. A net
will be termed Cauchy whenever for every
one can find
such that
holds for all indices
, see [
7]. Moreover, if every Cauchy net is symmetrically convergent, then
S is called complete, see [
7]. If we take a sequence instead of a net in the definition of completeness, then such a quantale-valued quasi-metric space is referred to as s-complete. Every complete quantale-valued quasi-metric space is necessarily s-complete.
Example 1 ([
7]).
Let us consider the value quantale . The mapping given by is a quantale-valued quasi-metric on Q and is complete, see Theorem 4.9 in [7].
Now, let us recall the definition of probabilistic metric space, see [
20]. Let
be the collection of distribution functions satisfying monotonicity and left-continuity, that is
,
A mapping is regarded as a left continuous t-norm whenever the properties below hold:
the operation ⋇ possesses both associativity and commutativity;
, for all ;
whenever , it holds that ;
,
see [
20]. As stated in [
20], a probabilistic metric is a mapping
that meets the requirements given below for all
and
:
,
where
and
is the top element of
according to the pointwise order and defined by
and
is referred as a probabilistic metric space (PMS). A sequence
in
S strongly converges to
if
is given, there exists
beyond which
holds. It is termed a strong Cauchy when, for any
, some
can be found with
Strong completeness of
means that any strong Cauchy sequence in
S possesses a strong limit within
S, as described in [
20].
As shown in [
6], PMSs can be obtained as a particular subclass within the framework of QVQMSs. In particular, consider the PMS
, where ⋇ be a left continuous t-norm. If we equip
the opposite pointwise order
defined by:
and take the binary operation ⊛ given by,
as the quantale operation, then it follows that
is indeed a value quantale and
is a QVQMS. Moreover, strong complete PMSs corresponds to an s-complete QVQMSs. We end this section by recalling the definition of action introducen in [
4]. We will consider the following definition of the action:
Definition 4.
Consider a value quantale . An action of on Q is a monotone mapping
such that, for all and the following conditions hold:
and for ;
;
;
.
Example 2.
[4] Given and , set
Then ⊗ defines an action.
3. Results on Coupled Fixed Points Within QVQMS
For convenience, we shall denote the structure endowed with the action ⊗ by and we shall refer to as quantale-action structure in the paper.
As introduced in [
3], the coupled fixed point has the following QVQMS-version:
Definition 5.
Consider a value quantale . Let be a QVQMS. The pair is a coupled fixed point of whenever
Theorem 1.
Consider a quantale-action structure , and let be an s-complete QVQMS. Consider a mapping satisfies the following condition for all :
where . Suppose that there exists a couple satisfying the following requirement:
Then, P admits a unique coupled fixed point in S.
Proof. Let
be a point satisfying condition (
4) and set
and
Then, by condition (
3), it follows that
Define
. Using the above inequalities and the monotonicity of the action ⊗, we have
When
, one can readily see that
is a coupled fixed point. Therefore, let us assume that
. By the definition of the well-above relation and inequality (4), for any
one can find
such that, whenever
, we obtain:
and
Applying the supremum to each side of the above two inequalities, we deduce:
Thus, we have
and
. Hence, the sequences
and
are Cauchy. Since
is s-complete, there exists points
such that
and
with respect to
. According to Theorem 2.9 in [
6], for each
one can find
with
and
such that, for all
,
and
. We now show that
is a coupled fixed point of
P:
Thus, we obtain
. Moreover, in a similar way,
. What is left is to prove that the uniqueness. Suppose, to the contrary, that
is a distinct coupled fixed point of
P. Then, we have
and
From the above inequalities, we obtain
Since, , this yields a contradiction. Consequently, P has exactly one coupled fixed point. □
Corollary 1.
Consider a quantale-action structure , and let be an s-complete QVQMS. Consider a mapping satisfies the following condition for all :
where and . Suppose that there exists a couple satisfying the following requirement:
Then, P admits a unique coupled fixed point in S.
Proof. We only need to verify that the contraction assumption (5) yields the one in (3). Let
be constants satisfying
. Take arbitrary elements
satisfying (5). Then we have
Hence, the proof follows from Theorem 1. □
Corollary 2.
Consider a quantale-action structure , and let be an s-complete QVQMS. Consider a mapping satisfies the following condition for all :
where . Suppose that there exists a couple satisfying the following requirement:
Then, P admits a unique coupled fixed point in S.
Proof. Take arbitrary
satisfying (7). Let
. Then, we obtain the following:
This completes the proof by the Theorem 1. □
Example 3.
Let . Consider a partial order ≾ defined by . Then, is a complete lattice. Moreover, let us define the quantale operation ⊕ as follows:
Take the action ⊗ on S defined by , for all . Then, is a quantale-action structure. Furthermore, equip S with the QVQMS δ given by . From Theorem 4.9 in [7], one can get that s-complete. According to this metric, the distances between the points can be easily computed, and they are presented in the table below:
Now, consider a mapping defined by
Obviously, there exists which satisfies the inequality (4). Therefore, the hypotheses of Theorem 1 hold, and is the unique coupled fixed point.
Remark 1.
Let be equipped with the usual order on the extended non-negative real numbers and with the ordinary adition as the quantale operation. In this case, quantale-valued quasi-metric spaces reduce to classical quasi-metric spaces. If a quasi-metric space is complete with respect to its symmetrization, then it is called a bicomplete quasi-metric space, see [1]. Hence, every bicomplete quasi-metric space can be viewed as a s-complete quantale-valued quasi-metric space. Moreover, consider the action ⊗ of on given by
for and , see [5]. Then, the following corollaries follow directly from the main results.
Corollary 3.
Consider a bicomplete quasi-metric space . Assume that the mapping satisfies the following condition for all :
where . Then, P admits a unique coupled fixed point in S.
Corollary 4.
Consider a bicomplete quasi-metric space . Assume that the mapping satisfies the following condition for all :
where and . Then, P admits a unique coupled fixed point in S.
4. Applications Within QVPMS and PMS
QVPMs were defined in [
16] as follows:
Definition 6 (Kopperman et al., see [
16]).
Consider a nonempty set S and value quantale . A mapping is referred as a quantale-valued partial metric whenever for all , the conditions below are satisfied:
,
,
,
.
The pair is referred as quantale-valued partial metric space (QVPMS).
The notion of 0-complete partial metric, originally given by Romaguera in [
18], will be carried over to the framework QVPMSs as follows:
Definition 7.
Consider a nonempty set S and value-quantale . Let be a QVQMS. A sequence is called θ-Cauchy if
that is, for any there exists such that for all , . If every θ-Cauchy sequence converges to a point such that , i.e., for any , there exists such that for all , , then is called -complete QVPMS.
Example 4. Consider a value-quantale . Let us define a mapping by , for all . Then, is -complete QVPMS. Indeed, we first establish that is a QVPMS. Let :
,
,
,
It is clear that the following inequality can be derived from the definition of supremum and condition of Definition 2.1 in [6]:
Moreover, from the property of Theorem 2.2 in [6], one can obtain:
If the supremum of both sides of inequalities and is taken, the following is obtained:
Therefore, we conclude that is a quantale-valued partial metric. Next, we prove that is -complete. Let be a θ-Cauchy sequence. Then, for any , there exists such that for all ,
Since is arbitrary, it follows that for all . Consequently, converges to θ, and since , we deduce that is a -complete QVPMS.
In the subsequent results, we draw inspiration from the work presented in [
10]. Our first aim is to demonstrate that Proposition 2.1 in [
10] can be generalized to the framework of QVPMSs.
Proposition 1.
Consider a value-quantale . Suppose that is a -complete QVPMS. Define a mapping by
Then, is a s-complete and symmetric QVQMS.
Proof. First, we show that is a symmetric QVQMS. We only verify the triangle inequality, since the other conditions are straightforward. Let . We now examine the following cases:
•
Case I. Let
. Then we have
•
Case II. Let
. It follows that
•
Case III. Let
. In this case, we obtain
•
Case IV. Finally, we consider when
. Then it s easiy to see that:
We now prove that S is s-complete. Let be a Cauchy sequence in . It is sufficient to consider the case where holds whenever . Then, and hence is a -Cauchy in . Because S is -complete, we can quarantee the existence of a point such that the sequence converges to with respect to . Therefore, for any , there exists such that for all , we have , and hence . Consequently, we get that is s-complete QVQMS. □
Corollary 5.
Consider a quantale-action structure , and let be a -complete QVPMS. Let be a mapping satisfying the following condition for all :
where . Suppose that there exists a couple satisfying the following requirement:
Then, P admits a unique coupled fixed point in S.
Proof. Proposition 1 ensures that
is s-complete and symmetric QVQMS; accordingly, it suffices to show that contraction condition (11) implies condition (
3), which completes the proof. Let
and suppose that (11) holds. Then, we have
where
. If
, the proof is straightforward; hence, we may assume that
. Therefore, we will examine the following conditions:
•
Case I. Let
and
. Then, we obtain
•
Case II. Let
and
. This implies that
•
Case III. Let
and
. Then, we get
Consequently, Theorem 1 ensures that P possesses exactly one coupled fixed point. □
As mentioned in the Preliminaries, QVQMSs can be seen as a generalization of PMSs. We conclude our paper with the following result which serves as an application of Theorem 1 to PMSs.
Corollary 6.
Consider the strong complete PMS , where ⋇ is assumed to be a left continuous t-norm. Assume that the mapping satisfies, for all , the inequality
where . Suppose further that there exists a pair such that
Then P admits a unique coupled fixed point.
Proof. Consider the quantale-action structure
, where
is defined on page 5 and ⊗ is given in (
1). Then
forms an s-complete QVQMS. We now verify that condition (13) implies condition (
3). Let us take
and
such that (13) holds. Under these assumptions, we get
From the definition of the opposite order relation, we obtain
Furthermore, condition (14) ensures condition (
4). Hence, by the Theorem 1, the existence of a unique coupled fixed point is guaranteed. □
5. Conclusions
Many generalizations of metric spaces have been obtained by modifying the classical metric axioms. For instance, by dropping the symmetry requirement, quasi-metric spaces were introduced, [
8]. Since many distance functions arising in real-life situations are inherently non-symmetric, quasi-metrics play a significant role in the mathematical modelling of various applied problems. Another important generalized metric structure, particularly relevant in theoretical computer science, is that of partial metric spaces, [
17]. Most of these generalizations have been achieved through suitable alterations of the standard metric axioms. In 1977, Flagg [
6] introduced quantale-valued metric spaces by replacing the classical value set
with a value-quantale. This structure provides an abstract algebraic model capturing the essential properties of the usual addition and usual order on the non-negative real numbers. Quantale-based frameworks have proven to be highly useful and flexible, especially in theoretical computer science. Indeed, many problems in computer science can be represented by functions assigning a solution to each problem instance; such functions are referred to as a solution operators, see [
21]. In [
21], Siedlecki employed quantale-valued metrics to introduce a generalized notion of solution operators, which has become an important tool in the study of computational problems modelled by the partially ordered sets. Motivated by these developments, in the present paper we have extended coupled fixed point theorems from classical metric spaces to the broader setting of quantale-valued quasi-metric spaces, within the framework of abstract analysis and without resorting to categorical language. We have shown that, under appropriate conditions, coupled fixed point results can still be established in these highly abstract structures. The theoretical results obtained are supported by illustrative examples, and their applicability is demonstrated through applications to QVPMSs and PMSs. As a direction for future research, we plan to investigate fixed point theorems for solution operators in quantale-valued quasi-metric spaces. In particular, we aim to develop best proximity point results in this framework and to explore their potential applications in theoretical computer science.
Use of Artificial Intelligence
The author declares that no Artificial Intelligence (AI) tools were used in the preparation of this manuscript.
Conflicts of Interest
The author declares that she has no conflict of interest.
Abbreviations
The following abbreviations are used in this manuscript:
| QVQMS |
Quantale-valued quasi-metric space |
| QVPMS |
Quantale-valued partial metric |
| FPT |
Fixed point theory |
| PMS |
Probabilistic metric space |
References
- Alegre, C.; Dağlı, H.; Romaguera, S.; Tirado, P. On the fixed point theory in bicomplete quasi-metric spaces. J. Nonlinear Sci. Appl. 2016, 9, 5245–5251. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Banach, S. Sur les Opérations dans les Ensembles Abstraits et leur Application aux Equations Intégrales. Fund. Math. 1922, 3, 133–181. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Bhaskar, T.G.; Lakshmikantham, V. Fixed Point Theorems in Partially Ordered Metric Spaces and Applications. Nonlinear Anal. Theory Methods Appl. 2006, 65, 1379–1393. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Flagg, B.; Kopperman, R. The asymmetric topology of computer science in: S. Brookes, et al., (Eds.),Mathematical Foundations of Programming Language Semantics. Lecture Notes in Computer Science 1993, 802, 544–553.
- Flagg, B.; Kopperman, B. R. Fixed points and reflexive domain equations in categories of continuity spaces. Electronic Notes in Theoretical Computer Science 1995, 1, 544–553. Available online: http://www.elsevier.nl/locate/entcs/volume1.html. [CrossRef]
- Flagg, R. C. Quantales and continuity spaces. Algebra Universalis 1997, 37, 257–276. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Flagg, R. C.; Kopperman, R. Continuity spaces: Reconciling domains and metric spaces. Theoretical Computer Science 1997, 177, 111–138. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Fletcher, P.; Lindgren, W.F. Quasi-Uniform Spaces; Marcel Dekker: New York, 1982. [Google Scholar]
- Gavazzo, F. Quantitative behavioural reasoning for higher-order effectful programs: Applicative distances. In: Dawar, A., Grädel, E. (eds.) Proceedings of the 33rd Annual ACM/IEEE Symposium on Logic in Computer Science, LICS 2018, 452–461.
- Haghi, R. H.; Rezapour, S. H.; Shahzad, N. Be careful on partial metric fixed point results. Topology Appl. 2013, 160(3), 450–454. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Jäger, G. The Wijsman structure of a quantale-valued metric space. Iranian J. Fuzzy Syst. 2020, 17, 171–184. [Google Scholar]
- Jäger, G. Quantale-valued uniform convergence towers for quantale-valued metric spaces. Hacettepe Journal of Mathematics and Statistics 2019, 48(5), 1443–1453. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Jäger, G. Sequential completeness for quasi-uniform spaces and a fixed point theorem. Mathematics 2022, 10, 2285. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Jäger, G.; Ahsanullah, T. G. M. Characterization of quantale-valued metric spaces and quantale-valued partial metric spaces by convergence. Applied General Topology 2018, 19(1), 129–144. [Google Scholar]
- Jäger, G.; Yao, W. Quantale-valued gauge spaces. Iranian Journal of Fuzzy Systems 2018, 15(1), 103–122. [Google Scholar]
- Kopperman, R. D.; Matthews, S.; Pajoohes, H. Partial metrizability in value quantales. Applied General Topology 2004, 5(1), 115–127. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Matthews, S.G. Partial metric topology. Proc. 8th summer conference on topology and its applications, ed S. Andima et al., Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, New York 1994, 728, 183–197.
- Romaguera, S. A Kirk type characterization of completeness for partial metric spaces. Fixed Point Theory Appl. 2010, 493298. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Sabetghadam, F.; Masiha, H. P.; Sanatpour, A. H. Some coupled fixed point theorems in cone metric spaces. Fixed Point Theory. Appl. 2009, 8, 125426. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Schweizer, B.; Sklar, A. Probabilistic Metric Spaces; North-Holland Series in Probability and Applied Mathematics; Elsevier Science Publishing Co. Inc., 1983. [Google Scholar]
- Siedlecki, P. Approximation, solution operators and quantale-valued metrics. Aequationes mathematicae 2017, 91(4), 745–758. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Weiss, I. Metric characterisation of connectedness for topological spaces. Topol. Appl. 2016, 204, 204–216. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
|
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content. |
© 2025 by the author. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).